FINAL

 

STATE BOARD OF EMERGENCY MEDICAL SERVICES

OHIO DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY

MEETING MINUTES

FEBRUARY 18, 2004

 

Chaired by:  David Fiffick

 

Board Meeting Date and Location:  February 18, 2004, Ohio Department of Public Safety, 1970 West Broad Street, Columbus, Ohio 43223

 

Board Members in Attendance:  Mr. Raymond Walendzak, Mr. Mark Resanovich, Mr. Mark Marchetta, Dr. Andrew Hawk, Mr. Mark Burgess, Mr. Curtis Chandler, Mr. James Holcomb, Ms. Kathryn Haley, Dr. William Cotton, Mr. Mark Mankins, Ms. Nancy Dragani, Mr. James Cress, Dr. Jonathan Groner, and Mr. Timothy Jakacki

 

Board Members Absent:  Mr. Carl Jordan, Dr. William Rogers, Ms. Charlene Mancuso, Mr. Martin Mace, and Ms. Darla Cooper

 

Staff Members Present:  Richard Rucker, Dr. J. D. Polk, Barbara Petrella, Heather Reed, Ellen Owens, John Kennington, Melissa Vermillion, Doug Orahood, Mike Glenn, Tim Erskine, Michaele VonVille-Feuillerat, Diane Walton, Carol MacDowell, Brian Pfeffer, Karen Mack, Walt Ashbridge, Cheryl Hupp, and Brenda Shaffer

 

Guest and Public Attendance:  Ralph Hammonds, Darryl Norviel, Barbara Pfelter, Beth Collis, Carolyn Lingel, Mary Ellen Hurban, Patty Bryan, and John Molnar

 

Mr. Fiffick welcomed all in attendance and called the February 18, 2004 Board meeting to order at 10:05 a.m.

 

Roll Call

Mr. Raymond Walendzak         Here

Mr. Carl Jordan

Mr. Mark Resanovich               Here

Mr. Mark Marchetta                Here

Dr. Andrew Hawk                    Here

Dr. William Rogers                  

Mr. Mark Burgess                    Here

Mr. Curtis Chandler                  Here

Mr. James Holcomb                 Here

Mr. David Fiffick                      Here   

Ms. Kathryn Haley                   Here

Dr. William Cotton                   Here

Ms. Charlene Mancuso

Mr. Martin Mace

 

Mr. Mark Mankins                   Here

Ms. Darla Cooper

Ms. Nancy Dragani                  Here

Mr. James Cress                      Here

Dr. Jonathan Groner                 Here

Mr. Timothy Jakacki                 Here

 

REVIEW AND APPROVAL OF THE JANUARY 21-23, 2004 EMS BOARD RETREAT MINUTES

 

It was noted on page 25 on the list of approved airway equipment and associated training equipment purchased from excess grant monies, color/metric CO2 detectors should be listed as a separate item.

 

ACTION:       Motion to approve the January 21-23, 2004 EMS Board Retreat  minutes as amended above.  Burgess first.  Chandler second.  None opposed.  Motion approved.

 

OPEN FORUM

No comments were brought forward.

 

REPORT AND RECOMMENDATION IN THE CASE OF CHERYL HEIDER (2002-213-102)

Elizabeth Collis, attorney for the Respondent, addressed the Board to highlight a few points about the case.  Ms. Collis reviewed with the Board the steps taken by the Respondent to overcome her addiction and noted that the Respondent takes full responsibility for her addiction.

 

Ms. Petrella, Assistant Attorney General, acknowledged Ms. Heider’s recovery process but advised the Board not to forget the aggravating circumstances. 

 

ACTION:       The Board moved for Executive Session in order to deliberate the Report and Recommendation of Cheryl Heider (2002-213-102).

 

Roll Call for Executive Session at 10:15 a.m.

Mr. Raymond Walendzak         Here

Mr. Carl Jordan           

Mr. Mark Resanovich               Here

Mr. Mark Marchetta                Here

Dr. Andrew Hawk                    Here

Dr. William Rogers

Mr. Mark Burgess                    Here

Mr. Curtis Chandler                  Here

Mr. James Holcomb                 Here

 

Mr. David Fiffick                      Here

Ms. Kathryn Haley                   Here

Dr. William Cotton                   Here

Ms. Charlene Mancuso

Mr. Martin Mace

Mr. Mark Mankins                   Here

Ms. Darla Cooper

Ms. Nancy Dragani                  Here

Mr. James Cress                      Here

Dr. Jonathan Groner                 Here

Mr. Timothy Jakacki                 Here

 

*****Board returned from Executive Session at 11:20 a.m.*****

 

*****Break 11:20 a.m. – 11:27 a.m.*****

 

ACTION:       In the matter of Cheryl Heider, Case No. 2002-213-102, the Board accepts the Findings of Fact and the Conclusions of Law.  The Board, however, does not accept the Recommendation of the Hearing Examiner to permanently revoke Respondent’s certificate to practice.  The Board instead recommends that Respondent (Cheryl Heider) retain her EMT-Paramedic certificate to practice under the following:

 

1.    Thirty (30) day suspension which is hereby stayed;

2.    Probation for three (3) years effective today;

3.    During the time of probation, Respondent shall submit to unannounced and random drug testing as designated by the Board, at her own expense;

4.    Respondent must submit to the Board written verification of authorization to practice from her Medical Director and her Fire Chief or Administrative Chief of EMS, within thirty (30) days of the date of this Order, or prior to starting practice;

5.    Respondent must submit a BCII check at her time of renewal at her own expense; wherefore no other convictions have been indicated;

6.    Respondent must notify the Board within ten (10) days of any violation of the Ohio Board of Nursing Alternative Program for Chemical Dependency and that any violation of such program shall be deemed a violation of this Board Order.

7.    Failure to comply with this Order of the Board shall result in further disciplinary action by the Board, in accordance with OAC Chapter 4765-10-03 and the Provisions of the ORC Section 119.

 

The reason for the Board’s actions is as follows: 

 

 

 

In reviewing the Report and Recommendation and the testimony, the Board finds that there is evidence that the Respondent admitted her error and willfully is complying with alternative treatment through the Ohio Board of Nursing.  Respondent has made a true and honest effort at her rehabilitation through the rigorous Ohio Board of Nursing Alternative Program for Chemical Dependency and the Respondent has the support of her Medical Control and EMS administration.

 

Therefore, the Board concludes that Permanent Revocation is not the only appropriate sanction in this case. 

 

ACTION:       Motion to approve Cheryl Heider to retain her EMT-Paramedic certificate to practice contingent upon the above listed stipulations.  Burgess first.  Holcomb second.  None opposed.  Motion approved.

 

CHAIR’S REPORT, DAVID FIFFICK

·      Executive Director Position

The interview process will take place in March for the Executive Director’s position.

 

·      House Bill 321

This bill is expected to be re-introduced in the near future with the amendment that removes the regional redistricting language. 

 

·      House Bill 41

This bill has passed the House but in a different version than the one the Board had originally seen.  Several state agencies have met legislators and addressed their concerns.  One area of concern is the creation of a new level of certification, Emergency Medical Assistant.  This is an alternative certification for individuals between the ages of 16 and 18 years old.  The Board was encouraged to learn as much as possible about this bill. 

 

INTERIM EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR’S REPORT, RICHARD RUCKER

·      National Registry

Pursuant to a request by the Board, Mr. Rucker sent a letter to the National Registry expressing the concerns of the Board on two issues.  Mr. Rucker received a reply from the National Registry and provided the Board with a copy.  The National Registry agreed to develop a system for reporting the scores of high school students prior to their 18th birthday. 

 

Also, the NHTA is undergoing development of the National EMS Scope of Practice Model.  Once this project is completed, the NREMT Board of Directors will make decisions regarding both of the Intermediate certifications.  William Brown, Jr., Executive Director the National Registry, has offered to address the Board regarding the Scope of Practice Model.

 

 

 

·      Consent Agreement

The Columbus Dispatch ran an article on February 4, 2004 about the Columbus Fire’s Consent Agreement.  The information provided by EMS is public record.

 

·      Staff Updates

The staff is currently conducting second interviews for the EMS-C Coordinator and Education Coordinator positions and hopes to have these positions filled in the near future.

 

·      Ohio Volunteer Medical Response Corps Committee

Mr. Rucker stated that he serves on this committee, which was formed to develop a way to provide medical volunteers with identification at the scene of a disaster.  The committee has partnered with ACEP, ODH, the federal Health Resources Service Administration, and Wright State University to sponsor a “Basic Disaster Life Support” training course.  The first training course will be conducted on February 23rd  and EMS will be represented by David Fiffick, Dr. Andrew Hawk, Richard Rucker and Brian Pfeffer.  The first phase of the identification is for volunteer physicians, physician assistants, nurses, pharmacist and licensed mental health professionals.  EMS identifications have been discussed for a future phase.

 

STAFF REPORTS

 

·      CE Sites, Ellen Owens

 

Recommendation of Continuing Education Site Approvals

New Site Without Reservation

 

Name                                                                        Personnel                                                          County

Community Hospital

Prog Coord – Rick Heironimus

Med Dir – Rohn Kennington, MD

Clark

Cridersville Volunteer Fire Department

Prog Coord – Rick Walls

Med Dir – Michael Humphrey, MD

Auglaize

PMP Joint Ambulance District

Prog Coord - Thomas Jorgensen

Med Dir – Dave Miramontes, MD

Hancock

St. Joseph Health Center

Prog Coor – Paul Minton

Med Dir – Gary Joseph, DO

Trumbull

179th AW Fire Department /

179th Medical Squadron

Prog Coord – Steven Swank

Med Dir – Richard Gajdowsli, MD

Richland

 

 

 

 

Total New Approvals For Year:  9

 

ACTION:       Motion to approve the above continuing education sites.  Burgess first.  Mankins second.  None opposed.  Fiffick abstained from St. Joseph Health Center.  Motion approved.

 

 

Recommendation of Continuing Education Site Approvals

Renew Site Without Reservation

 

Approval #             Name                                                                                                           County

2056

Ada-Liberty Rescue Squad

Hardin

1071

Akron Fire Department

Summit

1298

Brimfield Fire Department

Portage

1297

Cleveland Clinic Foundation

Cuyahoga

1010

Concord Township Fire Department

Delaware

1076

Coshocton Co. EMS

Coshocton

1043

East Palestine Fire Department

Columbiana

1068

Fayette County EMS

Fayette

1078

Harrison Township Fire Department

Montgomery

1019

Kettering Fire Department

Montgomery

1060

Kettering Medical Center

Montgomery

1053

Kirtland Fire Department

Lake

1081

Madeira & Indian Hill Fire Department

Hamilton

1064

Marion General Hospital

Marion

1086

Med-Trans, Inc.

Clark

1065

Medina General Hospital

Medina

1090

Montgomery Fire Department

Hamilton

1094

Norwich Township Fire Department

Franklin

1095

Norwood Fire Department

Hamilton

1099

Plain Township Fire Department

Franklin

1100

Pleasant Township Fire Department

Franklin

1031

Union Hospital

Tuscarawas

1112

Upper Arlington Fire Department

Franklin

1066

Wadsworth – Rittman Hospital

Medina

1001

Wayne Hospital

Darke

Total: 25

 

 

 

Total Renewals For Year:  44

 

ACTION:       Motion to renew the above continuing education sites.  Burgess first.  Mankins second.  None opposed.  Resanovich abstained from Akron Fire Department and Union Hospital.  Motion approved.

 

*Note: Harrison Township Fire Department’s approval number was listed as 1098 and it should have been 1078; the minutes have been changed to reflect the correct number.

 

 

·      Reciprocity, Ellen Owens

 

CERT #

NAME

STATE

LEVEL

32271

Badyna, Timothy A

GA

Paramedic

124008

Cox, Charles L

CA

Paramedic

124010

Good, Matthew D

IN

EMT-Basic

124009

Korb, Karen T

KY

EMT-Basic

123988

Land, David M

AK

EMT-Basic

124246

Lewellen, Kristen D

OK

Paramedic

69151

Nickerson, Andrew J

WV

EMT-Basic

73376

Von der Embse, Eric A

CO

Paramedic

97811

Williams, Scott J

PA

EMT-Basic

 

 

 

 

Total For Year:  9

 

 

 

 

ACTION:       Motion to ratify.  Holcomb first.  Burgess second.  None opposed.  Motion approved.

 

 

·      Accreditations, Michaele VonVille-Feuillerat

 

Initial Accredited School                 EMS Coordinator                Location                Level of Accreditation

Belmont EMS Training Program            James Clevenger                      Belmont Co.            FR, EMT-B, EMT-I, EMT-P

Staff recommends approval

 

ACTION:       Motion to approve above initial accreditation.  Burgess first.  Mankins second.  None opposed.  Motion approved.

 

******************************

 

Accredited School Renewal            EMS Coordinator                Location                Level of Accreditation

Four County Career Center                    Daniel P. Frederick                 Henry Co.               FR, EMT-I

Staff recommends approval

 

ACTION:       Motion to approve the above accredited school for renewal.  Burgess first.  Mankins second.  None opposed.  Motion approved.

 

Accredited School Renewal            EMS Coordinator                Location                Level of Accreditation

Geauga Regional Hospital UHHS           Tod Baker                               Geauga Co.              EMT-Basic

Staff recommends approval

 

ACTION:       Motion to approve the above accredited school for renewal.  Burgess first.  Mankins second.  None opposed.  Motion approved.

 

Accredited School Renewal            EMS Coordinator                Location                Level of Accreditation

Mid-East Career and Technology Ctrs   Mark Doerfler                         Muskingum Co.      First Responder

Staff recommends approval

 

ACTION:       Motion to approve the above accredited school for renewal.  Burgess first.  Mankins second.  None opposed.  Motion approved.

 

******************************

Ms. VonVille Feuillerat advised that Geauga Regional Hospital UHHS will be dropping the accreditation level of First Responder effective December 31, 2003.

 

******************************

 

 Offsite Training                  County                   Accredited School             Level(s) of Instruction

German Twp Fire & EMS      Clark                       Greene Co. Career Center       EMT-B

Staff recommends approval

 

ACTION:       Motion to approve the above listed offsite training.  Burgess first.  Mankins second.  None opposed.  Motion approved.

 

Offsite Training                   County                   Accredited School             Level(s) of Instruction

Kelleys Island EMS                Erie                          Northwest Ohio Paramedic    EMT-Intermediate

                                                                                Program at MCO

Staff recommends approval

 

ACTION:       Motion to approve the above listed offsite training.  Burgess first.  Mankins second.  None opposed.  Cress abstained.  Motion approved.

 

Offsite Training                   County                   Accredited School             Level(s) of Instruction

Green Township FD              Adams                     Southern Hills Career Ctr       First Responder

Staff recommends approval

 

ACTION:       Motion to approve the above listed offsite training.  Mankins first.  Burgess second.  None opposed.  Motion approved.

 

Offsite Training                   County                   Accredited School             Level(s) of Instruction

Pioneer FD                              Williams                  Williams Co. EMS                  First Responder

Alvordton/Milcreel FD           same                        same                                        same

Stryker/Springfield Twp FD  same                        same                                        same

The Ferro Corporation           same                        same                                        same

Staff recommends approval

 

ACTION:       Motion to approve the above listed offsite training.  Mankins first.  Burgess second.  None opposed.  Cress abstained.  Motion approved.

 

 

·      Extensions, John Kennington

 

NAME                                    CERT. #                  EXTENSION LEVEL            LENGTH                                EXT. TYPE

Allen, Melissa L.                  0088731                  Intermediate                          180                          Functioning

Ashton, Andrew S.              0089110                  Paramedic                              180                          Functioning

Axline, Richard A.                0011540                  Paramedic                              180                          Functioning

Ayers, Ronald E.